Oct 28 – Nov 3 · Case study

Duke's Mayonnaise

A mayonnaise nobody picks out, sold as a fight card for every sandwich its fans hold up.

Start to finish
1.5 h
Launched
Tue 11:28am
Posts read
15,733
Votes to pick it
10
Meetings
0
Film · Case study, 2:03

Photos by Duke's fans and owners on Instagram and Reddit, permission pending. Narration, score and sound made with AI.

What we heard

15,733 posts and comments · 6 platforms
  1. Duke's vs Hellmann's and the rest750, the loudest
  2. The tomato sandwich
  3. “Only Duke's” loyalty
  4. Cooking with it
  5. Switched and never went back
  6. Knowing your people, finding home
  7. Handed down or brought in by someone189, the deepest
  8. Worry about the recipe or the sale
  9. No sugar, the tang
  10. The Mayo Bowl
  11. Price
  12. Tied to someone who died

The fight with Hellmann's was the loudest. Who handed you the jar was the deepest. So every fan gets a fight, credited to whoever trained them.

Ten photos by Duke's fans on Instagram and Reddit: a striped heirloom tomato held on the vine, white bread over yellow tomato slices with a jar of Duke's behind, a big pink tomato held over a grill, a squeeze bottle of Duke's beside heirlooms, a fried bologna sandwich held over a paper plate, sliced pink tomatoes beside marbled rye, a homegrown tomato held at a porch door, a Triple 'Mater BLT held
What Duke's fans hold up: ten photos from Instagram and Reddit. Most are held in a hand, right up to the camera.

In their words

“I live in the South and my granny wouldn’t allow any mayo in her kitchen except for Duke’s.”

u/PistachioGal99 on r/Cooking. About 189 people said someone handed them Duke's.

The insight

Nobody picks Duke's. Somebody hands it to you.

People rarely describe choosing Duke's. Granny wouldn't allow anything else, Momma sent you back to the store, a husband's family brought the jar into the house. Then you make it your own: the tomato sandwich alone came up from 470 people, usually held over a sink.

The idea

Put up your Dukes.

The jar never changes, so the personality lives in what people make with it. Every fan's creation is billed like a fighter on a vintage fight poster: named in wood type, stamped with the 1917 seal and credited to whoever trained it. That credit carries the insight. Somebody handed you the jar. You put up what you made with it.

Tonight's card: three fans' photos framed on sunburst rays, a fried bologna sandwich named The Bologna Bomber, white bread over yellow tomatoes named Kid Tomato and a halved BLT sub named The Triple 'Mater, with a Same Recipe Since 1917 seal and the line Put up your Dukes.
Tonight's card.

Photos by @scott35950, @royalgoldjamie and @the_bodega_gso

Why Duke's gets to say it

1917the same recipe

Made with Eugenia Duke's original recipe since 1917, by Duke's own label: egg yolks only, no added sugar and its twang from distilled and cider vinegar. On October 26, 2026 the company said it again: “our recipes are unchanged.” With the jar fixed, the only thing left to change is what you make with it.

The spots

Film · 0:15, The Bologna Bomber

Photo by @scott35950. The announcer, score and sound are made with AI; the photo and type aren't.

Film · 0:15, Kid Tomato

Photo by @royalgoldjamie. The announcer, score and sound are made with AI; the photo and type aren't.

Film · 0:15, The Triple 'Mater

Photo by @the_bodega_gso. The announcer, score and sound are made with AI; the photo and type aren't.

The work

9 pieces
Fight poster on pink sunburst rays: a fried bologna sandwich held over a paper plate. The Bologna Bomber. Trained by @scott35950. Same recipe since 1917 seal. DUKE'S. Put up your Dukes. dukes.nonextsteps.com
Poster · 24 × 36 in

Photo by @scott35950

Fight poster on yellow sunburst rays: a hand lifting white bread off yellow tomato slices, a jar of Duke's behind. Kid Tomato. Trained by @royalgoldjamie. Same recipe since 1917 seal. DUKE'S. Put up your Dukes. dukes.nonextsteps.com
Poster · 24 × 36 in

Photo by @royalgoldjamie

Fight poster on green sunburst rays: a BLT sub held up in two halves, cut side out. The Triple 'Mater. Trained by @the_bodega_gso. Same recipe since 1917 seal. DUKE'S. Put up your Dukes. dukes.nonextsteps.com
Poster · 24 × 36 in

Photo by @the_bodega_gso

The campaign site at dukes.nonextsteps.com: Put up your Dukes over sunburst rays with the 1917 seal, then Tonight's Card with the three spots side by side, The Bologna Bomber, Kid Tomato and The Triple 'Mater, each with its trainer
Site · dukes.nonextsteps.com

Photos by @scott35950, @royalgoldjamie and @the_bodega_gso. A design, not live yet.

The Bologna Bomber motion poster at 9:16: the fried bologna sandwich on turning sunburst rays, the 1917 seal and the Trained by @scott35950 tag
Poster · 9:16 motion poster

Photo by @scott35950

How the week went

No regroups were held
  1. Wed

    Research

    Quiet

  2. Thu

    Research

    Quiet

  3. Fri

    Idea

    0.5 hours

    0.5 h research

  4. Sat

    Work

    Quiet

  5. Sun

    Work

    Quiet

  6. Mon

    Work

    1 hours

    1 h film

  7. Tue

    Ship

    Quiet

    Launched at 11:28am.

The trainers and the owners

Every photo here belongs to the fan or owner who posted it on Instagram or Reddit. Permission is still pending from all ten, and nothing runs until each says yes. The announcer, narration, scores and sound are made with AI; the photographs and type aren't. Spec work by No Next Steps, not affiliated with or endorsed by Duke's.